Home Opera The seventy fifth version of the Aldeburgh Competition rounded off with a uncommon go to to East Anglia of the celebrated Hallé Orchestra.

The seventy fifth version of the Aldeburgh Competition rounded off with a uncommon go to to East Anglia of the celebrated Hallé Orchestra.


Schoenberg: Pierrot Lunaire - Claire Booth, the Nash Ensemble - Aldeburgh Festival (Photo: Marcus Roth, (c) Britten Pears Arts)
Schoenberg: Pierrot Lunaire – Claire Sales space, the Nash Ensemble – Aldeburgh Competition (Picture: Marcus Roth, (c) Britten Pears Arts)

Schoenberg: Pierrot lunaire, Beethoven, Julian Anderson, Judith Weir, Mozart; Claire Sales space, The Nash Ensemble, Martyn Brabbins; Aldeburgh Competition at Britten Studio
Britten: Curlew River; Ian Bostridge, Duncan Rock, Peter Brathwaite, Willard White, Matthew Jones, Deborah Warner, Audrey Hyland; Aldeburgh Competition at Blythburgh Church
Britten: Suite from Dying in Venice, Mahler: Symphony No. 5; The Hallé, cond. Sir Mark Elder; Aldeburgh Competition
Reviewed by Tony Cooper (25 June 2024)

This yr’s Aldeburgh Competition has reached new limits with a roster of wonderful live shows and recitals not least by the tasteful musical feast served up for the final weekend. 

A cycle of fifty poems, Pierrot lunaire was printed in 1884 by Belgian writer, Albert Giraud (born Emile Albert Kayenbergh in Leuven in 1860) intently related to the Symbolist Motion who wrote poems in French. The protagonist of the cycle, Pierrot – the moonstruck and fantastical clown who wears a masks to cover one’s true emotions – is the well-loved comedian servant and ‘outsider’ of the Italian Commedia dell’Arte theatrical custom. Early Nineteenth century Romantics, reminiscent of Théophile Gautier, had been drawn to him by his Chaplinesque pluckiness and pathos.  

Due to this fact, exceptional in lots of respects, Giraud’s assortment is among the many most densely and imaginatively sustained works within the ‘Pierrot’ canon which attracted the eye of an unusually excessive variety of composers however it’s Schoenberg’s setting that’s probably the most famend and broadly thought-about one of many landmark masterpieces of Twentieth-century music. Though the composition is atonal, it’s not written within the twelve-tone approach that Schoenberg developed (and favoured) in his later years. 

The fee got here from Albertine Zehme, a chanteuse married to a Leipzig lawyer, asking Schoenberg to set a lecture textual content to music. Fully free within the number of poems, his alternative was, in fact, the French cycle of poems of Pierrot lunaire by Giraud translated by Otto Erich Hartleben. Deciding on 21 poems from the cycle, Schoenberg duly divided them into three distinctive teams: within the first (Drunk on the Moon, Colombine, The Dandy, A Pale Washerwoman, Valse de Chopin, Madonna, The Sick Moon Pierrot) Pierrot sings of affection, intercourse and faith; within the second (Evening, Prayer to Pierrot, Theft, Purple Mass, Gallows Tune, Beheading, The Crosses) he sings of violence, crime and blasphemy; within the third (Homesickness, Foul Play, Parody, The Spot on the Moon, Serenade, Journey Dwelling, O Historic Perfume) Pierrot goals of returning residence to Bergamo together with his previous haunting him. 

On the work’s première in 1912, the ensemble comprised Albertine Zehme (voice) with Hans W. de Vries (flute), Karl Essberger (clarinet), Jakob Malinjak (violin), Hans Kindler (cello) and Eduard Steuermann (piano). Based on Anton Webern, the première was an awesome success for performers and Schoenberg however obtained a foul press though many of the viewers, fascinated by the brand new sounds, responded moderately nicely to the efficiency general.  

Britten: Curlew River - Aldeburgh Festival (Photo: Marcus Roth, (c) Britten Pears Arts)
Britten: Curlew River – Aldeburgh Competition (Picture: Marcus Roth, (c) Britten Pears Arts)

However Pierrot lunaire on the Rudolfinum, Prague, on 24 February 1913, triggered uproar and mayhem with the viewers turning into one in all Schoenberg’s most horrifying and traumatic experiences which he remembered for the remainder of his life, main him to demand ensures for trouble-free performances at additional ‘Pierrot’ live shows. The première of Stravinsky’s The Ceremony of Spring carried out by Diaghilev’s Ballets Russes on the Theatre du Champs-Élysées, Paris, appeared two months after Schoenberg’s Pierrot lunaire, broadly thought-about probably the most infamous scandal within the historical past of music, mirrors the identical state of affairs. 

Fortunately, nobody had angst or anger etched into their faces on the Aldeburgh Competition in such an excellent and easy efficiency delivered by Claire Sales space with the efficiency properly sandwiched between Thursday’s Solstice (20 June) and Saturday’s Full Moon (22 June) and coinciding, too, with the anniversary of Peter Pears’ birthday. Heard within the intimacy and luxury of the Britten Studio (very best for works reminiscent of Pierrot lunaire) the gamers of The Nash Ensemble – Philippa Davies (flute), Richard Hosford (clarinet), Benjamin Nabarro (violin), Lars Anders Tomter (viola), Adrian Brendel (cello) and Alasdair Beatson (piano) – had been discovered on prime type. Are they ever off it? 

Schoenberg’s instrumentation is modern and trendy to the core as he makes use of a special pairing for every quantity other than the final when the complete ensemble comes collectively. Schoenberg additionally employs using ‘sprechstimme’ (‘speech-voice’) continuously utilized in Twentieth-century music and so intently related together with his compositions. He first used the approach in Pierrot lunaire though it was utilized by Engelbert Humperdinck a couple of years earlier in his melodrama, Königskinder, in 1897. 

A exceptional and internationally-renowned singer and ideal for Schoenberg, Claire Sales space has simply issued a few recordings marking the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the composer’s delivery specifically Pierrot lunaire and Expressionist Music: A Schoenberg Songbook (generously supported by the Schoenberg Centre, Vienna) pairing Schoenberg’s songs with eight of his personal work taking its cue from the composer’s assertion that ‘portray is identical to me as making music’. Mendelssohn, a gifted watercolourist, felt the identical means, too. On a visit to Switzerland in 1838, he wrote to his life-long buddy, Carl Klingemann, revealing that he had composed not even a little bit of music however sketched and drew total days to his coronary heart’s content material!  

Staying over for an additional live performance on the ultimate Saturday of the competition (22 June), Claire Sales space and The Nash Ensemble supplied a lovely programme performed by Martyn Brabbins comprising Beethoven’s Clarinet Trio in B flat, Op.11, Julian Anderson’s Three Songs, Judith Weir’s Distance and Enchantment and Mozart’s Piano Quartet No.1 in G minor.  

Scored for the uncommon mixture of clarinet, cello and piano, Beethoven’s Clarinet Trio, a piece of expansive and genial class, supplied a great ‘opener’ for a late-morning live performance within the Britten Studio. Composed in 1798, simply earlier than Beethoven turned his consideration to his first set of string quartets, the work discovered nice favour with a packed home with the sprightly and tuneful final motion ending a pleasant playful and lyrical piece. Comprising variations on ‘Pria ch’io l’impegno’(‘Earlier than I start this job, I want a snack’) from Joseph Weigl’s comedian opera, L’amor marinaro, which was all the trend in Vienna in 1797. Beethoven was fast off the mark to money in on it! 

Julian Anderson’s Three Songs so well-suited Claire Sales space’s voice. They had been merely pleasant. A 12-minute work, the primary track, ‘le 3 mai’, set to a textual content by Ahmed Essyad, written in 2020, focuses on the Covid-19 social restrictions with an excellent satirical-like line ‘I embrace you all, this kiss is pure, with out Covid’; the second ‘Tombeau’, set to a textual content by Stéphane Mallarmé, commissioned by the Birmingham Modern Music Group in 2017 for a celebration of the music of Debussy in 2018, was pure delight; the  third, ‘THUS’, a setting of the final verse of Henry Longfellow’s poem, Rain in Summer season, had members of The Nash Ensemble including percussive sounds to the efficiency by closely stamping their toes laborious on the boards of the stage (as a part of the rating, in fact!) similtaneously taking part in their devices with Anderson using a bass clarinet thus including an additional dimension to the general temper of the piece. 

In Judith Weir’s Distance and Enchantment, the composer sums up her piece as a musical essay about individuals who instantly disappear from residence by no means to return, a strikingly frequent prevalence these days. However what just isn’t such a standard prevalence is a sudden break in efficiency. Just some minutes into the piece, Adrian Brendel had a fright (the viewers, too, to a sure extent!) as he was up-and-ended when the piano stool he favours for efficiency collapsed – possibly below the pressure of Mozart! Shades of the British rock group, The Who, who would smash to smithereens stuff and the like on the finish of their efficiency.  

Nonetheless, choosing himself up from the ground, checking that no harm was achieved to his cello, unfazed and to a giant spherical of applause, he gingerly took to his new seat (Aldeburgh’s stage crew had been fast off the mark!) and the efficiency restarted as if nothing had occurred. Judith Weir, one of many composers-in-residence at this yr’s competition, attended the live performance. I questioned what handed via her thoughts. 

Anyhow, Distance and Enchantment takes the type of two meditations on conventional folksongs performed collectively with out a break handsomely carried out by the pianist and string trio of The Nash Ensemble. An excellent lot, actually! Due to this fact, ‘The Darkish-Eyed Gypsy’ from Northern Eire tells of a lady who, of her personal volition, leaves her comfy residence to roam the unknown world with a band of gypsies whereas in ‘A Ghaoil, Leig Dhachaigh Gum Mhàthair Mi’ from South Uist, Scotland, the story surrounds a younger lady who wanders a bit of too removed from residence on a darkish night time and is stolen away by the fairies. 

Harbouring a passionate allure, Mozart’s Piano Quartet No.1 has delighted audiences time and time once more and greater than delighted the packed home within the Britten Studio. The primary motion opens with a stern musical ‘name to order’ by all 4 devices taking part in in unison with the second motion comprising a beautifully-expansive melody full of a quiet dignity and a tinge of disappointment seemingly transporting one to a shimmering and intimate scene from one in all Mozart’s operas whereas within the quick and last motion, Mozart strikes one into the brightness of the day thus bringing the quartet to a becoming conclusion full of endlessly creative melodies, pleasure and heat that’s, I assume, the composer’s trademark! 

The primary of Britten’s three ‘Parables for Church Efficiency’, the state of affairs of Curlew River relies on Kanze Motomasa’s unhappy and emotional play, Sumidagawa, a hauntingly-moving story a couple of mom’s seek for her long-lost son who nervously finds out that after he has been kidnapped he’s later discovered lifeless. An enchanting story, Britten noticed it a few instances throughout his go to to Japan with Peter Pears in early 1956 in Tokyo’s Suidobashi Noh Theatre whereas Britten’s librettist, William Plomer, who lived in Japan in the course of the Twenties and who inspired Britten to discover Japanese theatre, transferred the standard setting of this Fifteenth-century play to the medieval Fenlands of East Anglia thereby presenting it as a Thriller Play.  

A significant undertaken for Britten, he decamped to Venice for six weeks to work on Curlew River discovering this metropolis (lovingly dubbed ‘La Serenissima’) one of many few locations apart from Suffolk the place he felt relaxed sufficient and in the proper atmosphere to compose. On its first efficiency in Orford parish church, devoted to St Bartholomew, on the 1964 Aldeburgh Competition, the critic of The Instances described Curlew River as ‘presumably the beginning of a brand new, maybe a very powerful, stage of Britten’s artistic life’. Finishing the Noh trilogy are The Burning Fiery Furnace (primarily based on the Outdated Testomony story of Nebuchadnezzar and the three Israelites) and The Prodigal Son (primarily based on the parable from St Luke’s Gospel).  

Directed by Deborah Warner, assisted by Isabelle Kettle, this new staging at Blythburgh church, devoted to the Holy Trinity and suitably dubbed the ‘Cathedral of the Marshes’, is a co-production with Britten Pears Arts and Advert Lib Productions and one of many highlights of the seventy fifth Aldeburgh Competition which has been a runaway success from begin to end.  

Curiously, there’s no conductor within the presentation of Noh drama. Britten, in fact, was music director for the unique manufacturing with pianist Viola Tunnard working alongside him whereas Peter Pears took the lead function in every work. Scored for small instrumental forces and an all-male solid, Britten makes nice use of musical symbolism in Curlew River reminiscent of using a flute to symbolize the ‘Madwoman’ and a French horn, the ‘Ferryman’.  

Blythburgh church is right for such shows as Curlew River and I fondly recall seeing a staging of the entire Noh trilogy right here by Mahogany Opera, directed by Frederic Wake-Walker, in 2013, the yr celebrating the centenary of Britten’s delivery. The solid was headed by tenor Mark Padmore with the Aurora Orchestra and Roger Vignoles as music director. In truth, I additionally had the pleasure of attending the world première of the Noh trilogy at Orford church in 1964 by the English Opera Group directed by Colin Graham and, certainly, later on the Edinburgh Competition in St Mary’s Cathedral in 1968 when the competition director, Peter Diamand, centered on the music of Schubert and Britten. 

By the way, Wake-Walker was introduced up in Suffolk the place, as a treble, he sang in three Britten operas at Snape Maltings together with, on the age of 11, Miles in The Flip of the Screw. Now a difficult and futuristic director and producer of opera and modern music-theatre, Wake-Walker’s famend for his ground-breaking work at main worldwide opera-houses and in unconventional areas, too. He was awarded Greatest Director on the 2019 Opera Awards for his productions of Peter Grimes (Oper Köln) and Ariadne auf Naxos (La Scala, Milan). 

Celebrating its sixtieth anniversary this yr, Curlew River was admirably led by Ian Bostridge because the Madwoman with Duncan Rock (Ferryman), Marcus Farnsworth (Traveller), Matthew Jones (Spirit of the Boy/Acolyte), Daniel Harrison (Spirit of the Boy/Acolyte), Albert Bate (Acolyte), Willard White (Abbot/Chief of the Pilgrims) with the Pilgrims coming from the Refrain of Britten Pears Younger Artists comprising Thomas Elwin, Thomas Herford, Hugo Brady, Jonathan Eyers, Felix Kemp, Jolyon Loy, Francis Brett, Jack Comerford whereas a bunch of seven instrumentalists – Hannah Gillingham (flute/piccolo), George Strivens (French horn), Luca Wadham (viola), Lucía Moreno (double-bass), Miriam Keogh (harp), Ryan Hepburn (percussion) and Joseph Ramadan (chamber organ) – got here from the Britten Pears Younger Artist Programme, led by Audrey Hyland, who, by the way, was workers pianist on BPYAP programs, a job first undertaken by Viola Tunnard. 

Casually dressed of their day-to-day garments, T-shirts, denims and the like, Curlew River solemnly opens with group of Monks gathering in the back of the church as a way to ceremonial course of alongside Blythburgh’s lengthy and imposing nave below the gaze of a number of elegantly-carved wood angels with outstretched wings, chanting the plainsong ’Te lucis ante terminum’ (‘To Thee earlier than the shut of day’) an outdated Latin hymn (which additionally opens the opposite two works within the Noh trilogy) earlier than robing in entrance of the chancel to enact the Thriller Play. 

In truth, many of the stage motion was centred upon the nave and Blythburgh has an prolonged nave to lots of its neighbouring church buildings due to this fact I felt that Deborah Warner’s manufacturing labored nicely in such an intimate and confined house whereas the musical forces discovered house within the south aisle by the chancel. On the work’s première the instrumentalists comprised Richard Adeney (flute), Neill Sanders (French horn), Cecil Aronowitz (viola), Stuart Knussen (double-bass), Osian Ellis (harp), Philip Ledger (chamber organ) and James Blades, percussion, comprising 5 small untuned drums, 5 small bells and one large-tuned gong. 

A small, distinctive and gifted solid was led by Ian Bostridge because the Madwoman. Shabbily wearing a lemon-green costume and darkish jacket, a damaged umbrella is held in a single hand and seemingly wandering as a ‘homeless’ individual, this slightly unhappy and confused character is travelling with a slightly worn and well-used quilt. Grief-stricken, agitated and distressed, on the lookout for her long-lost son took its toil with the function (created for Peter Pears) vividly portrayed by Bostridge who performed the half to the complete delivering an sincere and convincing account whereas his performing talents handsomely matched his vocal prowess.  

Roughly dressed, carrying an anorak, the storyteller within the pack, Duncan Rock, brilliantly portrayed the Ferryman (written for John Shirley-Quirk) whereas the robust deep bass voice of Willard White stamped his authority on the function of Abbot/Narrator thereby strengthening and enriching the Christian dimension of this compelling piece of Noh theatre. Though harbouring wealthy and numerous non secular influences these days the Noh custom is predominantly an inventive and literary type that has moved miles away from its non secular/ritual origins. The solid was accomplished by Marcus Farnsworth placing in a snug and rewarding efficiency as The Traveller (written for Bryan Drake) who, describing his nomadic life, has intentions to cross the Curlew River

Nonetheless, probably the most poignant second in the entire of this intense and fascinating drama surrounds the Ferryman’s story the place it’s abundantly clear that the boy he’s describing is the kid of the Madwoman. Damaged-hearted, she joins in prayer at her son’s graveside on the far financial institution of Curlew River and on the climactic second when all of the Monks are chanting collectively, the Spirit of the Boy (sung offstage by Matthew Jones, acted onstage by Daniel Harrison) is heard echoing them together with his spirit glowing above the tomb to reassure his mom: ‘Go your means in peace, mom. The lifeless shall rise once more. And in that blessed day. We will meet in heav’n.’ At this level, the Madwoman is redeemed, her insanity lifts which is lovingly depicted in a deep and shifting scene together with her singing a joyful and vibrant ‘Amen’ with the complete solid becoming a member of in signalling an indication of return and acceptance.  

The quiet and dignified ending is punctuated by the return of the robing music whereas the refrain of eight pilgrims resume their day-to-day apparel singing plainsong as they course of alongside the nave in direction of the west finish of the church thus mirroring the beginning of the efficiency. A very memorable manufacturing that obtained a standing ovation from an adoring viewers. 

The efficiency was recorded by BBC TV for future broadcast in a movie by Advert Lib Productions directed by Dominic Greatest. 

The ultimate ‘shout’ of Aldeburgh’s seventy fifth Competition gloriously opened with Britten’s Suite from Dying in Venice organized in 1984 by Steuart Bedford, a detailed affiliate of the composer, in a well-controlled efficiency of class and tenderness by the Hallé below Mark Elder. Stuart Bedford, in reality, performed the opera’s première on the 1973 Aldeburgh Competition. A steady orchestral work, it might nicely be described as an ‘operatic symphony’ and the rating flows smoothy and logically via the salient factors of the opera’s state of affairs falling into seven clearly distinct and recognizable sections: Summon to Venice; Overture to Venice; First Seashore Scene; Sight of Tadzio; Pursuit; Second Seashore Scene; Dying. 

In stark distinction to the lightness and melancholic rating to Dying in Venice, the Hallé turned their consideration to one of many large weapons of Nineteenth-century music, Gustav Mahler, delivering a nice rendering of the composer’s mighty fifth symphony written over the summers of 1901-02 on the composer’s vacation retreat at Maiernigg close to Maria Wörth, Carinthia, Austria.  

Written in three elements and comprising 5 actions, the ‘adagietto’, the shortest motion lasting about 10 minutes, discovered common reputation when Luchino Visconti used it in his 1971 movie, Dying in Venice. An immensely lyrical and evocative piece so endearing with emotional and passionate outbursts, Mahler supposedly wrote it to symbolize his love for his ‘soon-to-be spouse’ Alma.  

A grand and imposing work, the symphony obtained its première in Cologne’s equally grand and imposing Gürzenich Corridor performed by the composer however this Aldeburgh Competition efficiency by the Hallé, performed by Sir Mark Elder, proved a grand and imposing event, too, and introduced the curtain down on a extremely profitable competition which sees Sir Roger Wright, CBE, bow out of his publish as Chief Government of Britten Pears Arts on a excessive after serving a wonderful decade on the helm.  

And to mark Roger’s parting, Sir Mark Elder supplied the viewers a becoming encore in his honour with the strings of the Hallé delicately taking part in a mild rendering of Elgar’s Chanson de Nuit thus mirroring the opening live performance of the competition when the brass and percussion of the London Philharmonic blasted Snape Maltings Live performance Corridor with a totally satisfying Fanfare in Roger’s honour penned by Colin Matthews. The one distinction being that ‘the-man-of-the-moment’ then was simply Roger Wright – by the top of the competition he grew to become Sir Roger Wright. Congratulations!  

Word: A correspondent kindly clarified in regards to the ending of Curlew River – the boys in Curlew River. Each Matthew and Daniel sang on the finish, Matthew first from one finish after which half means via the strains, Daniel took over. It was Albert Bate who acted because the boys spirit, strolling up the aisle and interacting with Ian.” 

By no means miss out on future posts by following us

The weblog is free, however I might be delighted in the event you had been to indicate your appreciation by shopping for me a espresso.

Elsewhere on this weblog

  • Youthfully partaking: a visually trendy new Rake’s Progress on the Grange Competition made us actually take care of about these characters – opera assessment
  • A richly layered depiction of characters in all their fallibility: Monteverdi’s L’incoronazione di Poppea on the Grange Competition – opera assessment
  • The Sea and Shipsthe London Tune Competition celebrates the primary Delivery Forecast to be broadcast on British radio – live performance assessment
  • Way more than a chunk of historical past: Roderick Cox conducts Shostakovich’s Symphony No. 10 on the Royal Academy of Music – live performance assessment
  • Music like no different: Icelandic composer Gudmundur Steinn Gunnarsson’s Stífluhringurinn – report assessment
  • New colors in outdated sound worlds: the Portuguese duo, Bruno Monteiro & João Paulo Santos in Elgar, Debussy, Ravel & extra – report assessment
  • Time remembered: the seventy fifth version of the Aldeburgh Competition lovingly recreates the opening night time of 1948 Competition – live performance assessment
  • A disc that makes you suppose, but additionally satisfies as a recital in its personal proper: Songs for Peter Pears from Robin Tritschler & pals – report assessment
  • Second view: Anna Patalong makes her function debut as Puccini’s Tosca at Opera Holland Park – opera assessment
  • An plain present for melody: Charles Mauleverer’s Overture – report assessment
  • Dwelling

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*